Skip to content

Lexar SILVER PLUS vs PNY PRO Elite Prime (2026)

Rugged and compatibility-tested, or bigger and simpler? We compare the Lexar SILVER PLUS and PNY PRO Elite Prime microSD cards on speed, toughness and capacity.

Research Desk
Editor-approved · Updated November 12, 2026

Head-to-head comparison · Research-based · Affiliate links

We earn a commission from qualifying purchases made through our links, at no extra cost to you. It never decides our picks. As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases. How we make money

Lexar Professional SILVER PLUS microSDXC UHS-I Card vs PNY PRO Elite Prime microSD: which one should you buy?

Our Pick
Lexar Professional SILVER PLUS microSDXC UHS-I Card

Best for: Drone and action-cam shooters wanting a rugged, compatibility-tested card

The Alternative
PNY PRO Elite Prime microSD

Best for: Users who need maximum capacity at a reasonable price

The Lexar Professional SILVER PLUS microSDXC UHS-I Card vs PNY PRO Elite Prime microSD choice comes down to toughness versus capacity. Most buyers should pick the Lexar: it has the higher rated read speed, documented IPX7 water resistance and tested compatibility with DJI, GoPro, Nintendo and Steam Deck. The PNY is the better choice if you need more than 1TB on one card, since it goes up to 1.5TB.

The two cards are close on paper. Both are UHS-I, U3, V30 and A2 cards, both are mid-range in price, and both carry a limited lifetime warranty. The differences are in the details below.

Lexar Professional SILVER PLUS vs PNY PRO Elite Prime: speed

The Lexar is rated for up to 205MB/s read, and the PNY for up to 200MB/s. That 5MB/s gap is too small to matter in everyday use, so don't pick on read speed alone.

Write speeds are closer to a tie, with a catch on the smaller cards. The Lexar writes at up to 150MB/s on its 128GB to 1TB cards and up to 100MB/s on the 64GB. The PNY also reaches up to 150MB/s on higher capacities, but its 64GB and 128GB cards are listed at up to 110MB/s. If you're buying a 128GB card for burst photos, the Lexar's rated write speed is higher. At 64GB the PNY is slightly faster on paper (110MB/s against 100MB/s).

Both cards are V30 and U3, so both support 4K video recording. The Lexar's listing specifies 4K 60fps. The PNY's listing says V30 / U3 guarantees smooth 4K video capture, with a 30 MB/s minimum write speed. Both are also UHS-I only, so neither will give you UHS-II speeds. A common criticism of the PNY is that V30 is too slow for high-bitrate 8K video.

Both cards need the right reader to hit their headline numbers. PNY states that its maximum speeds require the PNY Performance Prime card reader, which is sold separately. Reviewers say the Lexar also needs a fast USB reader to reach top speeds, and some tests measured its reads below the rated 205MB/s. Treat both speed claims as best-case figures.

Edge: Lexar, narrowly, especially on 128GB cards and up. The gap is small.

Durability and device compatibility

This is where the Lexar pulls ahead. It is rated IPX7 (1m deep water for 30 min), with an operating temperature of -25°C to 85°C (-13°F to 185°F) and a storage temperature of -40°C to 85°C (-40°F to 185°F). It is also described as x-ray-, magnet-, shock- and drop-proof.

PNY describes its card as magnet, shock, temperature, water and X-ray proof. PNY doesn't publish an IPX rating, a water depth or a temperature range. That doesn't mean the card is fragile, but you can't compare the protection level number for number. If the card will sit in a drone, action camera or a bag that gets wet, the Lexar's documented rating is easier to trust.

Lexar has also tested the card for compatibility with DJI, GoPro, Nintendo and Steam Deck. PNY doesn't list device-specific testing. It does say the A2 rating lets apps run from the card, and reviewers say that suits phones, drones and action cameras. The Lexar's A2 class is aimed at phones, tablets and handhelds. PNY quotes the A2 figures (a minimum of 4000 IOPS read and 2000 IOPS write); Lexar doesn't publish those numbers.

Edge: Lexar, for anyone shooting in rough conditions or using a listed device.

Capacity and what's in the box

PNY wins on capacity. Its cards run from 64GB up to 1.5TB, while Lexar's run from 64GB to 1TB, with a 2TB size listed as coming soon on the Lexar Americas page. If you have a device that can use a very large card, 1.5TB is a real advantage.

Extras favour Lexar. Both include an SD adapter, so both can be used in full-size SD slots. Lexar also bundles its Recovery Tool, which is handy if you delete files by accident. PNY lists no equivalent software.

Reviewers raise a few practical points about the PNY. It takes a long time to fill with data and gets hot during long transfers. On the positive side, reviewers saw no thermal throttling in testing. For the Lexar, reviewers note its dark colouring makes it easy to lose outdoors, which matters for a card this small.

Edge: PNY for sheer capacity; Lexar for extras and recovery.

What experts say

The Lexar has the larger body of published reviews. TechRadar gave it 4.5 out of 5 and DroneXL gave it 9 out of 10, which gives it an expert average of 9 out of 10. It is also recommended in one expert buying guide. Reviewers praise its fast reads, writes of up to 150MB/s on 128GB to 1TB cards, 4K-ready V30 rating, IPX7 protection and tested device compatibility. The main criticisms are that it is UHS-I only, needs a fast reader and can read below its rated speed in some tests.

The PNY has one published expert score: MacSources gave it 9 out of 10. That is the same as the Lexar's average, but it is a single review, so it carries less weight. Reviewers praise its capacity of up to 1.5TB, its up-to-200MB/s reads, its A2 rating and the lack of thermal throttling. They criticise the need for PNY's separate reader to get the best speeds, the long time it takes to fill the card, the heat during long transfers and V30 being too slow for high-bitrate 8K video.

Both are well regarded. The Lexar has more evidence behind its score.

Choose Lexar Professional SILVER PLUS if…

01
Our Pick

Lexar Professional SILVER PLUS microSDXC UHS-I Card

9.3
Lexar Professional SILVER PLUS microSDXC UHS-I Card
Check price on Amazon

Specs from americas.lexar.com, lexar.com

Best for: Drone and action-cam shooters wanting a rugged, compatibility-tested card

Pick the Lexar if you want a tough, well-reviewed card with documented IPX7 water resistance and tested compatibility with DJI, GoPro, Nintendo and Steam Deck. It also has a slightly higher rated read speed and includes a recovery tool, and its 1TB maximum suits most devices.

Read our full Lexar Professional SILVER PLUS microSDXC UHS-I Card review →
Capacity
64GB, 128GB, 256GB, 512GB, 1TB (2TB listed as coming soon on the Lexar Americas page)
Warranty
Limited lifetime warranty
Read speed
up to 205MB/s
Form factor
microSDXC UHS-I
Write speed
up to 150MB/s (128GB–1TB); up to 100MB/s (64GB)
Bus interface
UHS-I

Reasons to buy

  • Up to 205MB/s read for fast file transfers
  • Up to 150MB/s write on 128GB to 1TB cards
  • V30 rating covers 4K 60fps video recording
  • IPX7 waterproof, plus x-ray, magnet, shock and temperature proof
  • Tested with DJI, GoPro, Nintendo and Steam Deck

Reasons to avoid

  • UHS-I only, so no UHS-II speeds
  • Needs a fast USB reader to reach top speeds
  • Some tests measured reads below the rated 205MB/s
  • Dark colouring makes it easy to lose outdoors
Expert reviews · average of 3
TechRadar
9.0
DroneXL (1TB model)
9.0
CameraJabber
10.0

Choose the Lexar if you shoot with a drone or action camera, or use a Nintendo or Steam Deck handheld, and you want a card with tested compatibility. It has a documented IPX7 water rating and a published temperature range, and it comes with the Lexar Recovery Tool. Its 1TB maximum is enough for most devices. Keep in mind it is UHS-I, so a fast reader is needed to see its top speeds.

Choose PNY PRO Elite Prime if…

02
The Alternative

PNY PRO Elite Prime microSD

9.0
PNY PRO Elite Prime microSD
Check price on Amazon

Specs from pny.com

Best for: Users who need maximum capacity at a reasonable price

Choose the PNY if you need more than 1TB on a single microSD card, as it goes up to 1.5TB. It suits buyers who prioritise capacity and value over the Lexar's device-compatibility testing and included recovery tool.

Read our full PNY PRO Elite Prime microSD review →
Capacity
64GB-1.5TB
Warranty
Limited lifetime
Read speed
Up to 200MB/s
Form factor
microSDXC with full-size SD adapter
Write speed
Up to 150MB/s (64GB and 128GB: up to 110MB/s)
Bus interface
UHS-I

Reasons to buy

  • Capacities reach 1.5TB, above the Lexar's 1TB
  • Up to 200MB/s read for quick transfers
  • Up to 150MB/s write on higher capacities
  • A2 rating suits phones, drones and action cameras
  • No thermal throttling seen in testing

Reasons to avoid

  • Best speeds need PNY's separate Performance Prime reader
  • Filling the card with data takes a long time
  • Card gets hot during long transfers
  • V30 is too slow for high-bitrate 8K video
Expert reviews · average of 3
TechRadar
8.0
Digital Camera World
10.0
MacSources
9.0

Choose the PNY if capacity is your priority. It goes up to 1.5TB, above the Lexar's 1TB. It's a good fit for people who value space over device-specific testing and an included recovery tool. Budget for the PNY Performance Prime reader as well if you want its best transfer speeds, and expect long fill times and warm transfers on a very large card.

Compare our picks side by side

The specs most of our picks share, from each maker’s spec page (— = not published). Expert score = the average of published expert reviews, which rate each product for its price. Scroll sideways on small screens.

SpecLexar Professional SILVER PLUS microSDXC UHS-I CardPNY PRO Elite Prime microSD
Best forOur PickThe Alternative
Expert score9.39.0
Price vs. these picksMiddleMiddle
Capacity64GB, 128GB, 256GB, 512GB, 1TB (2TB listed as coming soon on the Lexar Americas page)64GB-1.5TB
WarrantyLimited lifetime warrantyLimited lifetime
Read speedup to 205MB/sUp to 200MB/s
Form factormicroSDXC UHS-ImicroSDXC with full-size SD adapter
Write speedup to 150MB/s (128GB–1TB); up to 100MB/s (64GB)Up to 150MB/s (64GB and 128GB: up to 110MB/s)
Bus interfaceUHS-IUHS-I
UHS speed classU3UHS-I, U3 (Class 10)
Video speed classV30V30
Where to buyView on AmazonView on Amazon

The verdict

For most buyers the Lexar Professional SILVER PLUS is the better microSD card. It has a slightly higher read speed, clearer durability ratings, tested compatibility with popular devices, a recovery tool and the stronger set of expert reviews. The PNY PRO Elite Prime is a sensible alternative, and the right one if you need more than 1TB. Otherwise the Lexar is the safer pick.

Ready to buy?

  • Lexar Professional SILVER PLUS microSDXC UHS-I Card
    Our PickLexar Professional SILVER PLUS microSDXC UHS-I Card
    View on Amazon
  • PNY PRO Elite Prime microSD
    The AlternativePNY PRO Elite Prime microSD
    View on Amazon

Frequently asked questions

Is the Lexar SILVER PLUS better than the PNY PRO Elite Prime?

For most buyers, yes. The Lexar SILVER PLUS has a slightly higher rated read speed (up to 205MB/s against 200MB/s), a documented IPX7 water rating and tested compatibility with DJI, GoPro, Nintendo and Steam Deck. The PNY PRO Elite Prime is the better choice if you need more than 1TB, as it goes up to 1.5TB.

Which card is faster, the Lexar or the PNY?

The Lexar is faster on paper by a small margin: up to 205MB/s read against the PNY's up to 200MB/s. Both reach up to 150MB/s write on higher capacities. On 128GB the Lexar is rated at up to 150MB/s and the PNY at up to 110MB/s. Both are UHS-I and need a suitable reader for top speeds.

Which microSD card is more durable, the Lexar or the PNY?

The Lexar has the clearer durability claims. It is rated IPX7 (1m deep water for 30 min) and has published operating and storage temperature ranges. PNY says its card is magnet, shock, temperature, water and X-ray proof, but doesn't list an IPX rating or temperature range.

Does the PNY PRO Elite Prime hold more data than the Lexar SILVER PLUS?

Yes. The PNY PRO Elite Prime is available up to 1.5TB, while the Lexar SILVER PLUS tops out at 1TB, with a 2TB size listed as coming soon on the Lexar Americas page.

Can both cards record 4K video?

Yes. Both cards are V30 and U3. Lexar specifies 4K 60fps recording for the SILVER PLUS, and PNY says its PRO Elite Prime's V30 / U3 rating guarantees smooth 4K capture. Reviewers say the PNY's V30 rating is too slow for high-bitrate 8K video.

Do I need a special card reader for the Lexar or PNY?

To reach top speeds, yes. PNY says the PRO Elite Prime's maximum speeds require the PNY Performance Prime card reader, sold separately. Reviewers say the Lexar SILVER PLUS also needs a fast USB reader, and some tests measured reads below its rated 205MB/s.

Sources

Specs are taken from the manufacturers' official pages; expert recommendations from the publications below.

  • Lexar Professional SILVER PLUS microSDXC UHS-I Card: americas.lexar.com, lexar.com, bhphotovideo.com, techradar.com
  • PNY PRO Elite Prime microSD: pny.com, bhphotovideo.com, walmart.com

More buying guides